Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Official Welling Site -> - Welling United Fans Forum -> Welling United Fans Forum -> Pugh or Kedwell
Post Info TOPIC: Pugh or Kedwell
JgFc


troll catcher

Status: Offline
Posts: 11491
Date:
Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Pugh is better than Keds technically, Keds was strong and had a great ethic. But remember Robbins scored 29 goals in the conference one year that is diff class to anyone we've ever had. Bartley is the best scorer we've ever had but that was at a level below the conference. Then add in Gary Abbott who scored hundreds for us.

We've had some incredible strikers and Pughie must be up there with any of them, technically i do not believe we've had better and only Abbo could claim to be technically anywhere as good a footballer as Andy. Longevity must count. Inchy, Abbo were here for years.

I would go in this order for legendness

1 God
2 Inchy
3 Abbo
4 Pugh
5 Keds

and ive probably changed 2 and 3 every year or so.



__________________

Alexander O'Neal 1987 "I'm fed up cos all you wanna do is criticize "

Trollspotting

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Spills


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1476
Date:
Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Bit of  a debate on a Friday.

Who was the better striker for Welling?

*I say was, I know Pugh has not actually left yet.

 



__________________

"Passion for the game.......is Passion for the game" 'Have you got the Spills to pay the bills?'

Wings since 97'.

On work experience......
chelwing


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1852
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

A question I have asked myself recently. Different types of players which makes it difficult. Kedwell had raw power but just for the sure quality of some of his finishing I would go for Andy pugh.

__________________
Wingnut


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 2428
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

John Bartley - debate over!

In answer to your question I think Pugh is all round a better player.



__________________
Sherpa49


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 737
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

There's only one way to find out...



__________________
Kevin


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

What an absolute load of nonsense the above is ... Id go ...

1 Lloyd Blackman
2 Ellis Remy
3 Paul Whitmarsh
4 Tamar Tuna
5 Mark Watson

__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz
Spills


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1476
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Paul Whitmasrh - what a ledgend!!

 

Talking of Blackman

http://www.kentonline.co.uk/kentonline/sport/2012/january/19/kevin_watson.aspx



__________________

"Passion for the game.......is Passion for the game" 'Have you got the Spills to pay the bills?'

Wings since 97'.

On work experience......
Kevin


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Hasnt scored goals anywhere, and has had about 20 clubs ... anyone that signs him next season is blind, stupid or desperate.

__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz
Hales out


First X1 Player

Status: Offline
Posts: 100
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

He must have a great agent as he always finds a club. Slow, not really skillful no eye for goal, what a player! 



__________________
cj


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 499
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Why is Menga not being mentioned.

__________________
Kevin


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Because Menga was ok in comparison to Blackman

__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz
dogkilla


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 409
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Menga was total waste of time, blackman crap.

Pugh and kedwell served welling well so equal for me.

__________________
Spills


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1476
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

DK, get those splinters out of your ars!!



__________________

"Passion for the game.......is Passion for the game" 'Have you got the Spills to pay the bills?'

Wings since 97'.

On work experience......
bruno


Moderator

Status: Offline
Posts: 4158
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Pugh or Keds playing for Welling only? Has to be Pugh for me.

Keds has gone on to prove he can cut the mustard in League 2 and I see no reaaon why Pugh can't do equally well or better long term.

__________________

YOUTH are the future

****

"The worst thing you can do is make a committment and not meet it and I understand that."  Barrie Hobbins 14 August 2010

 
The Popes Pointy Hat


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 23
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

dogkilla wrote:

Menga was total waste of time, blackman crap.

Pugh and kedwell served welling well so equal for me.

I despair. How dare you slag off my beloved Lheureux Menga. He excited me every time he came onto the field.........................and I can assure you, that had nothing to do with his football ability.

 



__________________

It's all about the confidence
the_Knows


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 278
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

great topic. Kedwell for me i love his passion and i believe my dear friend cheveton one rubbed his steaming head when he jumped into the crowd away at st albans a few years back on a tuesday night.

Also if we are going to talk about club legends i think you need to consider time speant at club and general interactions with the club as a whole. for me lew watts and glen knight would get in the list of legends over kedwell and pugh.

__________________
Feed the Knows and he will score
cheveton


Youth Team

Status: Offline
Posts: 63
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Knighty, what a LAD!

 

always game for a cheeky wink at a friendly spectator!



__________________
straight from the horses mouth
Riscardo


First X1 Player

Status: Offline
Posts: 188
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Jerry Rosatti

__________________
Trundle


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 539
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Kedwell for me by a whisker.

__________________
JgFc


troll catcher

Status: Offline
Posts: 11491
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

cheveton wrote:

Knighty, what a LAD!

 

always game for a cheeky wink at a friendly spectator!

Hmm the yam yam ex mrs JgFc, spent the whole of one half when we played at Reading saying phwooooooooar every time Knighty went up for a corner. He probably got pulled off at half time.



__________________

Alexander O'Neal 1987 "I'm fed up cos all you wanna do is criticize "

Trollspotting

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
sladie


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 450
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Sherpa49 wrote:

There's only one way to find out...

 In a fight a good big-un always beat a good little-un.

Pugh is a good footballer as well as good striker, a bit more moblie than Danny.

Danny was a good striker for us, and progesses in the game,very effective.

Enjoy watching them both.

I think they could be a good pairing, one day it could happen.

Pughie gets my vote.... just.



__________________
Trigger


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1909
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 


What a very good question! I am in no way saying that either of them are in a different league from any of the many strikers that have graced our colours. The information below explores the things that have helped influence their lives off the pitch and have made them the players that they have become.


Education
AP went to Eaton and gained 8 top grade A level results and went on to Cambridge University to obtain an honours degree in Law.
DK when he wasn't bunking off attended Margate Secondary Modern. Whilst here he learnt how to fight, play cards and chat up girls.
Scores: AP 10/10.     DK 7/10

First job
AP had already been head-hunted whilst attending Cambridge and joined the UK's largest company HSBC as a trainee corporate lawyer.
DK was too busy hustling on the pool table to get a job. 
Scores: AP 9/10.     DK 6/10

Social Activities
AP is a regular at the Groucho Club, has a membership at Wimbledon tennis club and follows Formula 1 around the World with access into the drivers paddocks.
DK sneeks in through the back door of the pictures with his mates and is often seen in William Hill's having a flutter.
Scores: AP 9/10.    DK 7/10

Food
AP enjoys crispy salmon at one of Gordon Ramsey's restaraunts.
DK is on first name terms at Kebab World where he regularly has a large Donner with chilli sauce but no tomatoes or chilli peppers.
Scores: AP 9/10.    DK 8/10

Music
AP likes nothing better than listening to Strauss on his Bang & Olufsen music system.
DK enjoys plugging his head phones into his iPhone and moving his body to the sound of Pink Floyd, AC/DC and Thin Lizzy.
Scores: AP 1/10.    DK 10/10

Both players score an excellent 38/50. So what can we learn from this?
They are just great!



__________________
A stranger is a friend who you have not yet met.
Spitey


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 711
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Kedwell over Pugh for me and just to show the debate isn't over I'll go for Robbins as greatest.



__________________

Andrew Nicholson aka Courtjester


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 989
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Don't forget Lennie Dennis.....



__________________
BOOM BOOM BALLY


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 785
Date:
Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Trigger wrote:


What a very good question! I am in no way saying that either of them are in a different league from any of the many strikers that have graced our colours. The information below explores the things that have helped influence their lives off the pitch and have made them the players that they have become.


Education
AP went to Eaton and gained 8 top grade A level results and went on to Cambridge University to obtain an honours degree in Law.
DK when he wasn't bunking off attended Margate Secondary Modern. Whilst here he learnt how to fight, play cards and chat up girls.
Scores: AP 10/10.     DK 7/10

First job
AP had already been head-hunted whilst attending Cambridge and joined the UK's largest company HSBC as a trainee corporate lawyer.
DK was too busy hustling on the pool table to get a job. 
Scores: AP 9/10.     DK 6/10

Social Activities
AP is a regular at the Groucho Club, has a membership at Wimbledon tennis club and follows Formula 1 around the World with access into the drivers paddocks.
DK sneeks in through the back door of the pictures with his mates and is often seen in William Hill's having a flutter.
Scores: AP 9/10.    DK 7/10

Food
AP enjoys crispy salmon at one of Gordon Ramsey's restaraunts.
DK is on first name terms at Kebab World where he regularly has a large Donner with chilli sauce but no tomatoes or chilli peppers.
Scores: AP 9/10.    DK 8/10

Music
AP likes nothing better than listening to Strauss on his Bang & Olufsen music system.
DK enjoys plugging his head phones into his iPhone and moving his body to the sound of Pink Floyd, AC/DC and Thin Lizzy.
Scores: AP 1/10.    DK 10/10

Both players score an excellent 38/50. So what can we learn from this?
They are just great!

 Neither have your CLASS - TOP DRAW YET AGAIN



-- Edited by BOOM BOOM BALLY on Monday 23rd of January 2012 10:45:29 AM



-- Edited by BOOM BOOM BALLY on Monday 23rd of January 2012 10:46:38 AM

__________________
MarkX


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 5456
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

I would have both in the team right now!!!

__________________
Odin73


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 893
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Ollie Morah anyone

__________________
cj


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 499
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Odin73 wrote:

Ollie Morah anyone

 I will raise you Adrian Stone.



__________________
Kevin


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Yep, another wasted talent.

__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz
Spills


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1476
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Where did Sam Appiah and Mark Cooper end up after leaving us?



__________________

"Passion for the game.......is Passion for the game" 'Have you got the Spills to pay the bills?'

Wings since 97'.

On work experience......
JgFc


troll catcher

Status: Offline
Posts: 11491
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

cj wrote:
Odin73 wrote:

Ollie Morah anyone

 I will raise you Adrian Stone.

 Are you on a wind up?



__________________

Alexander O'Neal 1987 "I'm fed up cos all you wanna do is criticize "

Trollspotting

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Andrew Nicholson aka Courtjester


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 989
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Odin73 wrote:

Ollie Morah anyone

 Alongside Lennie - almost perfect.....



__________________
DickieD


First X1 Player

Status: Offline
Posts: 113
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Oi!!! Can you please leave my favourite Lennie Dennis alone please? I remember him doing a good job for us in the last three games of a season to keep us up (just) when we were lowly in the Vauxhall Conference ... however I accept we were lowly because of his performance for the whole of that season!  I seem to remember a few last minute goals at PVR against Farnborough to keep us up???  His idea of the offside trap made me cry sometimes, but I loved him for it!

Pugh or Kedwell: Pugh would win goal of the season every time, Defences would worry more about Kedwell being on the team sheet.  As everyone else is suggesting - I'd love to see them pairing up at some point.



__________________

Bringing the spirit of Ransom to our play-off efforts!
corbystation


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 45
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Martin 'Bunny' Sterling or Steve Greenway haven't had a mention yet! Unbelievable


__________________
corbystation


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 45
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

Oh. And Keds by a whisker but that's no bad reflection on Pughy

__________________
Andrew Nicholson aka Courtjester


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 989
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

DickieD wrote:

Oi!!! Can you please leave my favourite Lennie Dennis alone please? I remember him doing a good job for us in the last three games of a season to keep us up (just) when we were lowly in the Vauxhall Conference ... however I accept we were lowly because of his performance for the whole of that season!  I seem to remember a few last minute goals at PVR against Farnborough to keep us up???  His idea of the offside trap made me cry sometimes, but I loved him for it!

Pugh or Kedwell: Pugh would win goal of the season every time, Defences would worry more about Kedwell being on the team sheet.  As everyone else is suggesting - I'd love to see them pairing up at some point.

Er I was being serious. Scored plenty of goals in his career. I was thinking about Farnborough when I typed it....



__________________
DickieD


First X1 Player

Status: Offline
Posts: 113
Date:
RE: Pugh or Kedwell
Permalink  
 

I'll always remember his ultimate winner against Farnborough where he bedded himself in the crowd with his celebration, but Lennie no way near makes my top 10



__________________

Bringing the spirit of Ransom to our play-off efforts!
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
Official Welling Site -> - Welling United Fans Forum -> Welling United Fans Forum -> Pugh or Kedwell
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard