Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1526
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Sutton has had his red card and his three match ban overturned. 



__________________

Baile idir dha Abhain.



Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 2428
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Right decision but can't help thinking of the appeals we have done over the last few years which have all been upheld. One rule for the big clubs......

#justiceforsutton

 



__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Your player KAPPA should be hauled before standards committee and banned for 3 matches for his unprofessional behaviour again SUTTON and TRFC. I understand he has acted this way previously?

His action in cheating was disgusting, and unsporting. He should get the ban. 



__________________


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 645
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


TV footage does not give a clear view of the incident, an arm was definitely moved backwards but did it catch Kabba in the face? Obviously the FA have decided it didn't. Sutton and Kabba were niggling each other all match. The referee acted on what was told to him by the assistant referee on the Erith and Belvedere side. What did the official see that made him make that call?

__________________

 All postings lubricated by The Door Hinge Ale House 11 Welling High Street



Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

Your player KAPPA should be hauled before standards committee and banned for 3 matches for his unprofessional behaviour again SUTTON and TRFC. I understand he has acted this way previously?

His action in cheating was disgusting, and unsporting. He should get the ban. 


We don't have a player called Kappa.

The player, Kabba, is being hauled before the FA.

Players feigning injury, and indeed claiming every throw and free-kick even when they know it isn't theirs, does need to stop. But don't get annoyed with Kabba, everyone has been doing it for years, including your lot I imagine. It needs to stop across the board.

If he feigned it then I won't be complaining if he is punished, but I'd like to think that this sort of decision would be reciprocated when we are away to the "big clubs" now the rules have changed for this season. I didn't see us getting much of the rub of the green last season with red cards away for Gallagher, Turner, Bush, and for other people picking on us, like Halifax's hooligan kicking Beautyman off the park a few days before captaining and playing alongside him for the England C team.



__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz

cj


Playmaker

Status: Offline
Posts: 499
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

Your player KAPPA should be hauled before standards committee and banned for 3 matches for his unprofessional behaviour again SUTTON and TRFC. I understand he has acted this way previously?

His action in cheating was disgusting, and unsporting. He should get the ban. 


 We await a tranmere player to feign injury we might come on your forum and have a meltdown.



__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


We are new to the imbicile decisions the officials in National League are making. At our last home game, we had such a bad liner that the ref was constantly over ruling his decisions! 

Your boy has a history of this type of behaviour - you should'nt stick up for cheats! There are too many of them in the game these days.



__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


We certainly don't try to get players red carded illegally !



__________________


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 628
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Nurse, nurse. He's out of bed again.

__________________


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1526
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

We certainly don't try to get players red carded illegally !


 Yeh yeh! Im sure Tranmere are perfect in everyway. Has your chairman sent the cheque to pay for the smashed windows in the changing rooms yet. I wonder if the FA are looking in to that as well.



__________________

Baile idir dha Abhain.



Club Legend

Status: Online
Posts: 7008
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

I understand he has acted this way previously?


 Is that a statement or a question?

You obviously know Kabba better than we do (only his 3rd game for us) but I seem to recall John Aldridge 'stretching the laws' when wearing a Tranmere shirt.

I saw no tv angle to prove the call either way. 

Will Gary Brabin be hauled up by the FA for his comments about the officials? 



__________________

I know I'm biased. What's wrong with that?



New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Your foot line says an educated football man. Your comments beg to differ!



-- Edited by Tranmerefan2 on Wednesday 9th of September 2015 08:19:30 PM

__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Brabin was telling the truth! As proven by the review board!!!!



-- Edited by Tranmerefan2 on Wednesday 9th of September 2015 08:20:54 PM

__________________


Admin

Status: Offline
Posts: 2550
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Sutton should have been sent off in the first half for blocking a goalbound shot with his arm. Therefore whilst I think it's fair that he had his red card overturned, he shouldn't have been on the pitch come half time.

I eagerly await to hear of a Tranmere player feigning injury....it happens at all levels of the game.

__________________

Welling United FC. Banging on the walls of Woking dressing rooms since 1963..



Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 720
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Keep up footnotes are wings wit the educated man refers to a former manager comments

__________________

 PREMIERSHIP - CHAMPIONSHIP -SINKINGSHIP - ABANDONSHIP



Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 628
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

Brabin was telling the truth! As proven by the review board!!!!



-- Edited by Tranmerefan2 on Wednesday 9th of September 2015 08:20:54 PM


Really? I wasn't aware there had been a review board to consider Brabin questioning the integrity of the referee and, in particular, the fourth official.



__________________


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 2428
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Tranmerefan2 wrote:

Brabin was telling the truth! As proven by the review board!!!!



-- Edited by Tranmerefan2 on Wednesday 9th of September 2015 08:20:54 PM


 First time for everything.

Apart from the ridiculous rant about the fourth official throwing the ball back too quickly for the Tranmere players to react....priceless.

And strangely no comment from you or Mr Brabin about your goal from the corner that never was....



__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 35
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


I think everyone is missing a point here. As I understand it the TV footage is inconclusive, so an element of doubt remains. So perhaps reducing the red card to a yellow would be fair. As it is the "injured" player has now been deemed guilty and a cheat, despite not having the chance to defend himself and despite the decision taken by the officials on the day. Where is the basic justice in this process, regardless of the team / players involved. 



__________________
JFO


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1650
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Maybe we'll appeal?

__________________
Graham
J


Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1767
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


I don't want to sound like I have a chip on my shoulder but it is annoying that it always seems to be the smaller clubs like us who get punished for crap like this when the bigger teams get away with it

just wait until the weekend when a big name prem player does it and nothing happens to him but small Welling get punished

__________________


New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 35
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Don't worry KSA will soon be back to save the day!



__________________
JFO


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


As an educated football ghost, i fail to comprehend how a player can take a swing at a player and get a red card overturned. Do we assume that it is ok to swing at player now as long as you do not connect?

__________________


I'm an educated football ghost



Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 713
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Would Tranmere have been treated the same as Welling have by the FA if the roles had been reversed. I doubt it somehow.



__________________



New Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 35
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


If the FA are now reversing the Refs decisions, how about reversing the decision to award them that corner, which wasn't, that led directly to their goal?



__________________
JFO


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 720
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


My take for what it was worth - it was  an off the ball incident that the assistant referee spotted ( I looked across at the linesman and he had his flag raised.) and informed the referee via the headphones, a off the ball incident would not necessary have been pick up by the TV cameras if it was following the ball.  hence, lack of clear video evidence one way or the other.

Regardless of lack of video evidence, something occurred for the assistant referee a reason the bring the incident to the referees attention.

I would of thought now day's the conversations between the assistant ref and the referee are recorded and if that is the case I am surprised that would not have been used as evidence. Second thoughts probably a walkie talkie set from Maplins.



-- Edited by morph on Thursday 10th of September 2015 04:47:47 PM

__________________

 PREMIERSHIP - CHAMPIONSHIP -SINKINGSHIP - ABANDONSHIP



Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 720
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


morph wrote:

My take for what it was worth - it was  an off the ball incident that the assistant referee spotted ( I looked across at the linesman and he had his flag raised.) and informed the referee via the headphones, a off the ball incident would not necessary have been pick up by the TV cameras if it was following the ball.  hence, lack of clear video evidence one way or the other.

Regardless of lack of video evidence, something occurred to give a reason for the assistant referee to the bring the incident to the referees attention.

I would of thought now day's the conversations between the assistant ref and the referee are recorded and if that is the case I am surprised that would not have been used as evidence. Second thoughts probably a walkie talkie set from Maplins.



-- Edited by morph on Thursday 10th of September 2015 04:47:47 PM


 



__________________

 PREMIERSHIP - CHAMPIONSHIP -SINKINGSHIP - ABANDONSHIP



Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 1909
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


As the original decision has been overturned, that to me suggests that there was enough evidence supplied for the appeal panel to be happy with making it. From the footage that we have all seen it is not conclusive that Kabba was or was not hit. Is it possible that Sahr or someone else has said something to that fact and that is why he has been charged? A new ruling for this year and I'm sure that the FA will want to be seen as implementing a firm stance to send out a message. Welling are not in a position to appeal if it is going to cost money, so it will be an easy win for the governing body. It would be harsh if Kabba receives a 3 game ban on the evidence supplied though.

__________________
A stranger is a friend who you have not yet met.


Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 720
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


I admit my earlier comments were purely based on what I saw on the day, but I have to agree with Trigger, that for a decision to be overturned there must be enough evidence available to overturn a decision - I would also suspect Kabba will get a three match ban as this will be reported and everyone will be aware of the rule.





-- Edited by morph on Thursday 10th of September 2015 06:29:04 PM

__________________

 PREMIERSHIP - CHAMPIONSHIP -SINKINGSHIP - ABANDONSHIP



Club Captain

Status: Offline
Posts: 944
Date:
Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Of course Tranmere getting the rightful red overturned would have nothing to do with their owner being the ex Chief Executive of the FA.



-- Edited by TheGhostOfJodyBrown on Thursday 10th of September 2015 08:49:45 PM

__________________


I'm an educated football ghost



Club Legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 3008
Date:
RE: Tranmere are successful in Sutton Red card appeal
Permalink  
 


Our friends at Tranmere have been very quiet about their MOTM as well, given their manager felt them worthy of all three points.

 

http://www.thefootballnetwork.net/main/s383/st190402.htm

 



__________________

Thou shalt support Welling and Faz

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard