Well I've just about started to get over the disappointment of our last performance at PVR.
Lets all try to put that behind us, at least from the start, tomorrow and get right behind the team. Macclesfield at home is an entirely winnable match and we are due a big home performance.
With Boring Wood away to Forest Green tomorrow its a great chance for us to create a bit of a gap between us and them.
Hopefully KSA can drive the team on to victory!
COYW!
__________________
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh When the Wingssssss
Almost a Damascene conversion, Chris. I agree with you though, time for me and others to banish all negative comments during the match and to fully encourage our team. If it does not work, we can have a damn good moan afterwards.
One of our best home performances of the season. But what we lacked today but had in our previous 4 home wins was luck. Of course we lacked a decent striker, or any kind of threat at set pieces, but then we have lacked that all season.
A change at the top is required as the current trio seem unable or unwilling to address this.
-- Edited by Chris on Saturday 19th of December 2015 06:56:21 PM
__________________
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh When the Wingssssss
One of our best home performances of the season. But what we lacked today but had in our previous 4 home wins was luck. Of course we lacked a decent striker, or any kind of threat at set pieces, but then we have lacked that all season.
A change at the top is required as the current trio seem unable or unwilling to address this.
-- Edited by Chris on Saturday 19th of December 2015 06:56:21 PM
I fully respect your view Chris but in the same post you've said it was "one of our best performances of the season" but want the management sacked as well.
The strikers we have were signed because they were the best we could obtain at the time of signing them. KSA and Kabba have all shown glimpses of what they can achieve. The only people that can bring them back to their best, are KSA and Kabba themselves. A new manager will not get more out of them. We signed Tash to give more depth to the squad, and was the best option we have at the time. I believe he could perform at this level but sadly his performances have been somewhat lackadaisical to put it mildly. People claiming we turned down Tyrone Marsh need to remind themselves why he left (££££££).
As I've said before, the board have the real overview of the clubs finances and it's down to them to decide whether money would be better spent on a new striker or whether a gamble should be taken on a new manager. We might not have money for either.
Whatever will be, will be. In the meantime we need to support the lads who gave their all today. We have to remind ourselves that most of them are u21 (correct me if I'm wrong) and most have never played at this level before. Many of them have the potential to be the next Jamie Vardy or Charlie Austin but they need us to support them and give them that belief.
I believe we can get three points from Dover. The team just need to keep doing the things we did right today, hit the training ground hard to iron out the little mistakes, and to go into the Dover game with the same positivity and belief that got the team three points against bigger teams like Gateshead, Kidderminster and Lincoln, as well as valuable points against Forest Green, Tranmere and Eastleight.
One of our best home performances of the season. But what we lacked today but had in our previous 4 home wins was luck. Of course we lacked a decent striker, or any kind of threat at set pieces, but then we have lacked that all season.
A change at the top is required as the current trio seem unable or unwilling to address this.
-- Edited by Chris on Saturday 19th of December 2015 06:56:21 PM
I fully respect your view Chris but in the same post you've said it was "one of our best performances of the season" but want the management sacked as well.
The strikers we have were signed because they were the best we could obtain at the time of signing them. KSA and Kabba have all shown glimpses of what they can achieve. The only people that can bring them back to their best, are KSA and Kabba themselves. A new manager will not get more out of them. We signed Tash to give more depth to the squad, and was the best option we have at the time. I believe he could perform at this level but sadly his performances have been somewhat lackadaisical to put it mildly. People claiming we turned down Tyrone Marsh need to remind themselves why he left (££££££).
As I've said before, the board have the real overview of the clubs finances and it's down to them to decide whether money would be better spent on a new striker or whether a gamble should be taken on a new manager. We might not have money for either.
Whatever will be, will be. In the meantime we need to support the lads who gave their all today. We have to remind ourselves that most of them are u21 (correct me if I'm wrong) and most have never played at this level before. Many of them have the potential to be the next Jamie Vardy or Charlie Austin but they need us to support them and give them that belief.
I believe we can get three points from Dover. The team just need to keep doing the things we did right today, hit the training ground hard to iron out the little mistakes, and to go into the Dover game with the same positivity and belief that got the team three points against bigger teams like Gateshead, Kidderminster and Lincoln, as well as valuable points against Forest Green, Tranmere and Eastleight.
COYW!
Thats the point Faz signed these players in late May/ early june when he did not need to. Also did he need to put them on contract or just give them rolling contracts? A new manager may be able to persuade them that their futures lie elsewhere. Perhaps Loui could do this himself, although time is running out!
It may have been one of our better home performances but that is indicative of how poor we ve been all season rather than how well we played today.
-- Edited by Chris on Saturday 19th of December 2015 08:22:42 PM
__________________
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh When the Wingssssss
And Tyrone didn't leave for money. He was on loan to us and was then signed by Ebbsfleet. Wrong again. Regardless, if you were working somewhere and a similar company offered you a lot more money to move to them you would take it. So would I and many others. Why should football be any different
In the summer we made a decision to sign Kabba who had to make a step up as opposed to Tyrone who scored goals at this level.
KSA did play well at the back end of the season, but i think having Roscoe and Dom Vose helped that.
The things that you post that are not correcr are undermining your argument. You wanted Jody Brown to stay and that would have relegated us. I believe that sticking with Loui also means we will get relegated. How long do you keep plugging away at things?
All this talk about what we can afford is also wrong. In our first season we had Beautyman, Franks, Berqvist, Dyer, Guthrie, Roscoe. Any of them in my opinion would walk into this team. The budget has not changed since then, so we were able to bring those types of players in then, why can't we do it now?
-- Edited by Polo on Saturday 19th of December 2015 08:25:00 PM
__________________
Welling United FC. Banging on the walls of Woking dressing rooms since 1963..
Wings Til I Die. Im out at present and my lengthy reply isn't practical on a phone. For now could you perhaps name your starting X1 if everyone were fit please.
And Tyrone didn't leave for money. He was on loan to us and was then signed by Ebbsfleet. Wrong again. Regardless, if you were working somewhere and a similar company offered you a lot more money to move to them you would take it. So would I and many others. Why should football be any different
In the summer we made a decision to sign Kabba who had to make a step up as opposed to Tyrone who scored goals at this level.
KSA did play well at the back end of the season, but i think having Roscoe and Dom Vose helped that.
The things that you post that are not correcr are undermining your argument. You wanted Jody Brown to stay and that would have relegated us. I believe that sticking with Loui also means we will get relegated. How long do you keep plugging away at things?
All this talk about what we can afford is also wrong. In our first season we had Beautyman, Franks, Berqvist, Dyer, Guthrie, Roscoe. Any of them in my opinion would walk into this team. The budget has not changed since then, so we were able to bring those types of players in then, why can't we do it now?
-- Edited by Polo on Saturday 19th of December 2015 08:25:00 PM
Actually if you look back, you'll see that I suggested Faz as manager after Jamie left. Whilst on the poor run with Jody I couldn't see he point of paying off Jody after less than ten games in charge when I couldn't think Of anyone who would be able to perform the miracle of keeping us up. Ironically Faz, MM and PB proved me wrong.
Changing management, like then, will be a huge gamble. As I've said it's up to the board whether they choose to spend money on a new manager rather than strengthening the squad. Also if the management team were sacked now, who would be interim manager?
And Tyrone didn't leave for money. He was on loan to us and was then signed by Ebbsfleet. Wrong again. Regardless, if you were working somewhere and a similar company offered you a lot more money to move to them you would take it. So would I and many others. Why should football be any different
In the summer we made a decision to sign Kabba who had to make a step up as opposed to Tyrone who scored goals at this level.
KSA did play well at the back end of the season, but i think having Roscoe and Dom Vose helped that.
The things that you post that are not correcr are undermining your argument. You wanted Jody Brown to stay and that would have relegated us. I believe that sticking with Loui also means we will get relegated. How long do you keep plugging away at things?
All this talk about what we can afford is also wrong. In our first season we had Beautyman, Franks, Berqvist, Dyer, Guthrie, Roscoe. Any of them in my opinion would walk into this team. The budget has not changed since then, so we were able to bring those types of players in then, why can't we do it now?
-- Edited by Polo on Saturday 19th of December 2015 08:25:00 PM
Actually if you look back, you'll see that I suggested Faz as manager after Jamie left. Whilst on the poor run with Jody I couldn't see he point of paying off Jody after less than ten games in charge when I couldn't think Of anyone who would be able to perform the miracle of keeping us up. Ironically Faz, MM and PB proved me wrong.
Changing management, like then, will be a huge gamble. As I've said it's up to the board whether they choose to spend money on a new manager rather than strengthening the squad. Also if the management team were sacked now, who would be interim manager?
You're digging a bigger hole then aren't you? On what grounds at that time, when Jamie left, was he the right choice? having had no managerial experience, no established stable team behind him, and still being a very regular starter for the club on the pitch.
It seems, summarising some of your posts, you wouldn't have got rid of Jody, don't want to get rid of Faz, don't want to drop KSA. Are you just someone that avoids any sort of decision?
It is indeed up to the board. Thank goodness it isn't up to you. We'd all be sitting on our hands/crossing our fingers/hoping for the best, until the 89th minute of the final league game when we'd wake up and smell the coffee once its too late.
if they are not gone after Dover I would really be shocked. I cant see us beating Dover the most would be a score draw but who will score for us? Vidal is always on the bench and any dangerous player we have like Bakare is now a sub and the management seem to want to pick a player who is unfit and not sharp enough for this level of football. Performances by some of the bright lights like Porter and Harris are beginning to tail off because there is no end product from their efforts. Where is our captain in all of this? he should be taking a lead on the field but very few times does that happen and yesterday it was a poor performance-yes lots of effort but all we do is kick the ball up in the air and hope. why cant they put the ball on the ground and play with it. When we do this we negate the size and power threat that the bigger teams always pose. Southport beat Bromley 5-3 yesterday only because they can score goals-how long will this go on with the ''happy with my squad'' mentality of the 3 amigos. I dont understand anyone who wants to stick with this, perhaps they are expecting lots of wins in the South but I have got news for you, we go down there and we arent getting out of it for many years. and there are better teams in there than us on our present form. Wake up those of you who are happy with the mess! yes Welling have a difficult decision to make because Loui is a good man and we all like him-but we must not forget we support Welling and not one man(3) and at present it is not working
I thought Willard did well yesterday and could hear him instructing players and telling porter off for being offside when he really shouldn't have been, much better in the middle. Think they play KSA as they think we need a big man to win headers etc but neither him or rash can do that job, I think we should be playing on the floor and just play a front 3 of Kabba, Harris and porter. At least they'd be faster then most defenders and create chances.
Can someone please explain the genius behind our substitutions please.
Having got the starting XI wrong, AGAIN, in my opinion, we then come out for the second half and have no subs warming up. The first change brings one big useless lump off to be replaced by another, whilst a decent attacking threat and our top scorer both sit in the dugout, no doubt reading their information and listening to instructions as the three stooges would put it.
Then we bring on Vidal, good move, although I am sure it was through gritted teeth. Time for a goal, oh no, hang on, we then take off our MOTM and arguably best player and replace him with Bakare, meaning we have FOUR forwards on the pitch in Porter, Harris, Bakare and Tash, meaning Vidal has to sit deep in midfield given he's one of only two in there. Wasted again.
Bakare then does more in the first two minutes than some "strikers" have managed all season.
And we end the game with Bakare through the middle and Tash out on the right side of a front three/four.
Bakare - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him
Vidal - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if played in a suitable position.
Kabba - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if only for 60 minutes.
Wellard - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if he is played in the correct position (and this might conflict with Vidal)
Fagan - has shown on occasion he has a contribution to make, if selected, although this may now be diminished due to the weight of splinters in his backside!
KSA - I'm still waiting for evidence, with these players around him, could be a while.
Tash - I'm still waiting for evidence, with these players around him, might be longer.
If we had consistently picked the players that had demonstrated a contribution and found a system that allowed them to make that contribution then I would agree you are gambling purely on a different manager making a motivational difference. We may have no money, we may have some but I can't tell you if we need to spend it or not because I don't know if what we already have if selected and played in a formation to suit would be good enough. Does anyone feel we are doing this?
WTID, if you employed a builder to do some plumbing and they consistently sent an electrician to do the job you'd not be happy, you'd probably def them off and get a different company to do the job. We well know as its football our business is not going to go to the next one down the road so you are then left with trying to force the bloody company to send the metaphorical plumber. And that might mean getting the staff manager changed.
If you are an experienced manager and can't make it work you'd expect the boot. If you are inexperienced you have to rapidly pick up and demonstrate the ability to learn and adapt if you aren't successful and that is not currently being outwardly demonstrated in either results or selection.
In a League where we have to get everything right pretty much to stay in it, if we played our best contributors and that isn't good enough, I don't go down happy but I feel we did what we could. I can live with that in the League below. I had 14 years or feeling we didn't give it our best shot last time round and that wasn't fun. I don't really want that again but at the moment that scenario is firmly on the cards, which is doubly bloody annoying given some of the crap and financially hamstrung teams in this division.
If the current management team are trying to prove a point they had better get it to work pretty damn quickly against someone at our level and pile up some credible evidence otherwise the only point they are proving is they are not adaptable, skilful or fast enough learners for the current task.
Bakare - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him
Vidal - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if played in a suitable position.
Kabba - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if only for 60 minutes.
Wellard - has shown he can contribute something in the League with our current players around him if he is played in the correct position (and this might conflict with Vidal)
Fagan - has shown on occasion he has a contribution to make, if selected, although this may now be diminished due to the weight of splinters in his backside!
KSA - I'm still waiting for evidence, with these players around him, could be a while.
Tash - I'm still waiting for evidence, with these players around him, might be longer.
If we had consistently picked the players that had demonstrated a contribution and found a system that allowed them to make that contribution then I would agree you are gambling purely on a different manager making a motivational difference. We may have no money, we may have some but I can't tell you if we need to spend it or not because I don't know if what we already have if selected and played in a formation to suit would be good enough. Does anyone feel we are doing this?
WTID, if you employed a builder to do some plumbing and they consistently sent an electrician to do the job you'd not be happy, you'd probably def them off and get a different company to do the job. We well know as its football our business is not going to go to the next one down the road so you are then left with trying to force the bloody company to send the metaphorical plumber. And that might mean getting the staff manager changed.
If you are an experienced manager and can't make it work you'd expect the boot. If you are inexperienced you have to rapidly pick up and demonstrate the ability to learn and adapt if you aren't successful and that is not currently being outwardly demonstrated in either results or selection.
In a League where we have to get everything right pretty much to stay in it, if we played our best contributors and that isn't good enough, I don't go down happy but I feel we did what we could. I can live with that in the League below. I had 14 years or feeling we didn't give it our best shot last time round and that wasn't fun. I don't really want that again but at the moment that scenario is firmly on the cards, which is doubly bloody annoying given some of the crap and financially hamstrung teams in this division.
If the current management team are trying to prove a point they had better get it to work pretty damn quickly against someone at our level and pile up some credible evidence otherwise the only point they are proving is they are not adaptable, skilful or fast enough learners for the current task.
A good summing up of the situation, looking at the post match interviews does not fill me with much hope that the current management have any intention of changing anything, so, for me, the Boxing Day game is their last chance.
First and foremost I couldn't fault their effort and commitment of the starting XI on Saturday (well 90.91% of them anyway) Fagan stepped in at centre half and did ok, Corne and Lee as most weeks gave it their best shot and I thought Wellard was possibly our best player in the first half. But once again in the last third we offered little or nothing. And once again what were the substitutions about. One big lump off replaced by another big lump. One player in the "number ten" role replaced by another player in the "number 10" role. I half expected the third change to be King for Mcentegart but we did change the shape a little for the last few minutes (quite how Bakare was third choice centre forward option on Saturday is beyond me)
Rather than the "information" that we keep hearing about being fed to the players how about we deal in a few cold, hard facts.
Home goals in the last three games at PVR = 0
Shots on target in the last three games at PVR = 3/4* (I know it was one against Southport and none against Carlisle so I reckon it was 2/3 on Saturday) I should say that having read the NLP yesterday their reporter reckoned we had 9 shots on target so the reporter was either not actually there or he had hit the Christmas sherry a bit hard?!
Lowest scorers in the league - Welling United (21 goals from 24 games) In fact the lad that scored for Macc on Saturday (who incidentally is on loan from a Conference North club for the season) has only scored three less himself than our entire squad has managed so far this season?!
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out where our problems lie but do we really think that the three amigos are the people to solve this problem?? We have three centre forwards - two of which are very similar in size and ability and sadly in effort too and another one, who one of the manager's openly admitted earlier in the season had injury problems, and has not started a game since the end of October. This has been a problem since August and here we are at Christmas and nothing has changed - two many contracts given out at the beginning of the season leaving us little or no room for manoeuvre and three people who are quite frankly too stubborn or just too stupid to see what is staring them in the face.